1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. What's Better for Diabetes: Sugar or Sugar Substitutes?

What's Better for Diabetes: Sugar or Sugar Substitutes?

by Suresh, 11 Dec 2023

Although that piece of chocolate cake is quite alluring, a small voice tells me it's not worth the calories and sugar. However, as you attempt to leave, a louder voice commands, Go ahead. You are in the lead since you had a diet drink with lunch and a yoghurt with aspartame for breakfast.

This kind of reasoning is only one of the reasons why some experts advise against using sugar substitutes and artificial sweeteners, especially if you have diabetes or have noticed your weight starting to creep up. The science is pointing to reasons why you should pause before giving foods with artificial sweeteners a second thought, and the chorus is growing louder as a result.

We've relied on artificial sweeteners for years to provide taste without calories or a spike in blood sugar, but it looks like it's time to change that.

Artificial sweeteners, according to researchers, may encourage "metabolic dysregulation." Because it is bad if it sounds that way. Translation: Artificial sweeteners appear to cause issues in the same way that sugar does by interfering with your body's normal reaction to glucose and insulin, complicating rather than facilitating weight loss attempts, and increasing your risk of developing prediabetes and diabetes, particularly if you are already overweight.

Sucralose Is Treat By Fat Cells Like Sugar

In a recent study, scientists initially examined human fat-derived stem cells in the lab while giving some cell samples of the sugar substitute sucralose but not others. Stem cells can develop into fully developed cells of fat, muscle, cartilage, or bone. After around 12 days, it was discovered that the meal with sucralose added had greater fat build-up than the dishes without it.

Why did the cells start to fatten up? Sucralose appeared to alter the expression of the glucose transporter gene in the lab samples. The glucose transporter gene facilitates greater cell entry of sugar or, in this case, sugar substitutes. But if too much enters the cells, it turns into fat storage.

Not what you'd anticipate. In comparison to cells not exposed to these sweeteners, it was discovered through stem cell research those low-calorie sweeteners encouraged more fat storage within the cells. Also, the greater the concentration of sweeteners introduced to the cells, the more fat that was accumulated. [Sugar substitutes] are interpreted as glucose by the cells.

It's best not to rely on sugar substitutes to satisfy your sweet need.

A crucial caution is provided by the developing body of data on sucralose and fat storage, especially for people who are battling with unwelcome weight gain. The researchers discovered a likely mechanism to account for a compelling drawback of using artificial sweeteners.

It has recently been determined that there is not enough information to make a firm determination about whether substituting them for caloric sweeteners in food and beverages reduces the overall amount of added sugars and carbohydrates or has other positive effects on things like hunger, weight, or risk factors for metabolic disease. According to certain experts, the professional panel's recommendation has to be updated.

Later, more research on the advantages and disadvantages of sugar alternatives was conducted. He pointed out that while short-term studies have shown that popular artificial sweeteners, when used in place of sugar, may lower a person's overall calorie intake, the advantages were usually very small or non-existent.

Potential [positive] benefits are likely to be diminished, and in some cases eliminated, by compensatory eating behaviours including justifications like the one where someone justifies eating that slice of cake by saying that she drank a diet soda earlier.

How the Glass Looks Is Very Important.

When you drink it, sugar's effects on your health are significantly worse. In a study including 18,000 adults from all over the United States, those who drank the most sugary drinks, such as soda (soft drinks), punch, drinks with fruit flavours, and fruit juices, had a higher risk of dying from heart disease and other conditions.

We monitored these people for almost seven years. and when the authors took into account factors including smoking, age, body weight, alcohol consumption, income, region of the country, and level of physical activity, the results remained consistent. The highest fatality rate was observed, approximately twice as high as that of those who drank the fewest sugar-filled beverages.

Now How To Please a Sweet Tooth?

Furthermore, "It's giving them false hope" because these items [with artificial sweeteners] are targeted for obese people. The marketing message for these products is that if you consume them, you won't gain weight. Despite the fact that this is false, there is no need to turn sugar, but rather to be aware of the downsides of both ''real'' sugar and its artificial substitutes.

8 Sugar-Free or Sugar-Substitute-Free Ways to Enjoy Sweets

When none of the solutions above work for you, you can always turn to Stevia, a plant-based alternative sweetener. Just use it sparingly and seldom. It's possible that you will start to prefer just strong added sweets as you get more dependent on them.